FN Herstal Firearms banner

What is the Scar 17s Barrel life in non-f/a

22K views 15 replies 11 participants last post by  Cadpack  
#1 ·
What does FN state the barrel replacement schedule/usable life is on a Scar 17? I am curious after reading lucky gunners recent report on Brass V.S. Steel and barrel life.
 
#3 ·
The reason i ask is the 5.56 tests don by lucky gunner are showing 5000-10k barrel life. Steve at adco did a ss barrel test to 15,000+ . I ask because of 1) barrel availability and 2) it depending, i have could shoot out the barrel. Not at 55,000 rounds but if on a scale close to the 5.56 tests it is a possibility.
 
#6 · (Edited)
Realize that you can cook a barrel non F/A as well, lots of full mag dumps can burn out the barrel in less than a thousand rounds (barrel type and rate of fire dependent).

For a rifle it seems to be in the 10-20K rounds - realize that unless you have a Kaboom, it wont just stop working. You'll see decreasing bullet velocities, increased wear, and decreasing accuracy over time... point being that you'll have some indication that the barrel is going downhill and have time (hopefully) to acquire a new one.

SCAR barrels are out there, but not easy to find and are pricey. Again, most people who are able to burn out a barrel fall into the following categories

(1) Military / LEOs - they don't pay for the ammo or the rifle and get a replacement for free - so they typically don't care
(2) High end Competitors - they usually have sponsors, get ammo cheap / free, as well as rifles - so they really don't care, not to mention as they go for accuracy, often change weapons / barrels early to keep them very accurate.
(3) Reloaders / avid shooters - people who understand that weapons and components have a finite life span and plan for their replacement

Honestly, with both barrel assemblies coming in around $1100-1300, if I shot enough to burn through either of my SCARs barrels, I'd probably just start looking for a complete SCAR 16/17 rifle - either lightly used or new Then either swap to using the new rifle, or pull the barrel for a replacement and strip the rest of the gun down as parts (either to keep or sell).

JMO, YMMV,

Rhino
 
#8 ·
Realize that you can cook a barrel non F/A as well, lots of full mag dumps can burn out the barrel in less than a thousand rounds (barrel type and rate of fire dependent).

For a rifle it seems to be in the 10-20K rounds - realize that unless you have a Kaboom, it wont just stop working. You'll see decreasing bullet velocities, increased wear, and decreasing accuracy over time... point being that you'll have some indication that the barrel is going downhill and have time (hopefully) to acquire a new one.

SCAR barrels are out there, but not easy to find and are pricey. Again, most people who are able to burn out a barrel fall into the following categories

(1) Military / LEOs - they don't pay for the ammo or the rifle and get a replacement for free - so they typically don't care
(2) High end Competitors - they usually have sponsors, get ammo cheap / free, as well as rifles - so they really don't care, not to mention as they go for accuracy, often change weapons / barrels early to keep them very accurate.
(3) Reloaders / avid shooters - people who understand that weapons and components have a finite life span and plan for their replacement

Honestly, with both barrel assemblies coming in around $1100-1300, if I shot enough to burn through either of my SCARs barrels, I'd probably just start looking for a complete SCAR 16/17 rifle - either lightly used or new Then either swap to using the new rifle, or pull the barrel for a replacement and strip the rest of the gun down as parts (either to keep or sell).

JMO, YMMV,

Rhino
Why not just buy a barrel blank and have the gun rebarreled? You would have all of the parts that are not currently available (gas block, etc).

Pat
 
#14 · (Edited)
Cold Hammer Forging is the answer you seek.

The rifling(or polygon) is beaten into the metal instead of drilling and cutting material away. It is compressed, hammered and the molecules are lined up in much the same way that forged Japanese Nihonto is.

M4s and Civilian weapons are drilled and rifling cut out of it. The US Military formerly only speced Cold Hammer Forged barrels on belt fed machineguns so there was a wide disparity in barrel life between individual and support weapons.

That technology has been used in many high end European military weapons for decades and now an even further refined version from FNH is used in our SCARs.
 
#13 ·
Probably from rate of fire. They were trying to shoot 10,000 through each gun in what appears to be a few days in that test. 17 30 round mag dumps will really heat up a barrel.

This isnt even close to a practical rate of fire, and they even said that themselves. I wouldn't compare this with the barrel life of any gun seeing resonable use. Some carbine classes are like 1200 rounds in two days with plenty of time to cool down between strings of fire.
 
#15 ·
As has been previously stated by Rhino, heat is any barrel's worst enemy. The more heat, the quicker the barrel dies.

The manufacturing process doesn't determine barrel life unless we're discussing non-plated bores.

The hard chrome plating can only stand so much before its compromised and the barrel is no longer considered useable.

MG barrels typically receive twice the plating build-up when compared to the infantry's fielded weapon such as the M4.

Some barrel manufacturers for the M2 offer a Stellite lined barrel option to extend barrel life in the throat area to extend throat life. The downside to Stellite is it's expensive and approximately doubles the barrel cost.

No free lunch, no matter how we take a bite...

.02

-SS